|
Sign In to gain access to subscriptions and/or personal tools.
|
Ambiguous, circular and polysemous: students' definitions of the "balance of nature" metaphor
Corinne Zimmerman
Department of Psychology, Campus Box 4620, Illinois State University, Normal, Illinois 61790-4620, USA, czimmer{at}ilstu.edu
Kim Cuddington
Ohio University
The "balance of nature" metaphor has been used to explain the functioning of natural systems from ancient times and continues to be invoked in popular culture, in spite of controversy regarding its use in the scientific community. We demonstrate that undergraduate students in the United States believe this term is descriptive of real ecological systems, and continue to do so after instruction in ecological science. A content analysis of students' definitions of the "balance of nature" and its causes varied widely with multiple, often contradictory, interpretations. A second survey confirmed that the range of definitions generated by students was representative of the larger educated population. Common responses included population regulation, species interactions, absence of disturbance and Nature. We speculate that the lack of a fixed meaning for the balance of nature term could lead to problems in education, public policy, and the transmission of ecological concepts to the general public.
References
- Boyd, R. (1993) "Metaphor and Theory Change: What is `Metaphor' a Metaphor For?,'" in A. Ortony (ed.) Metaphor and Thought, pp. 381—532. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
- Cicero (1938) De natura deorum, trans. H. Rackham. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
- Cooper, G. (2001) "Must There Be a Balance of Nature?," Biology and Philosophy 16: 481—506.[CrossRef]
- Cuddington, K. (2001) "The `Balance of Nature' Metaphor and Equilibrium in Population Ecology," Biology and Philosophy 16: 463—79.[CrossRef]
- Derrida, J. (1978) Writing and Difference, trans. A. Bass. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
- Eden, S. (1996) "Public Participation in Environmental Policy," Public Understanding of Science 5: 183—204.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
- Egerton, F.N. (1973) "Changing Concepts of the Balance of Nature," Quarterly Review of Biology 48: 322—50.[CrossRef]
- Forbes, S.A. (1887) "The Lake as a Microcosm," Bulletin of the Peoria Scientific Associations pp. 77—87. Reprinted in Bulletin of the Illinois State Natural History Survey (1925) 15: 537—50.
- Grotzer, T.A. and Basca, B.B. (2003) "How Does Grasping the Underlying Causal Structures of Ecosystems Impact Students' Understanding?," Journal of Biological Education 38: 1—14.
- Groves, F.H. and Pugh, A.F. (2002) "Cognitive Illusions as Hindrances to Learning Complex Environmental Issues," Journal of Science Education and Technology 11: 381—90.[CrossRef]
- Hastings, A., Hom, C., Ellner, S., Turchin, P. and Godfray, H.C.J. (1993) "Chaos in Ecology: Is Mother Nature a Strange Attractor?," Annual Reviews of Ecology and Systematics 24: 1—33.
- Hogan, K. (2002) "Small Groups' Ecological Reasoning while Making an Environmental Management Decision," Journal of Research in Science Teaching 39: 341—68.[CrossRef][Web of Science]
- Kingsland, S.E. (1985) Modelling Nature: Episodes in the History of Population Ecology. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
- McCloskey, M. (1983) "Naive Theories of Motion," in D. Gentner and A.L. Stevens (eds) Mental Models, pp. 299—324. Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.
- Miller, J.L. and Bartsch, K. (1997) "The Development of Biological Explanation: Are Children Vitalists?," Developmental Psychology 33: 156—64.[CrossRef][Web of Science][Medline]
[Order article via Infotrieve]
- Orne, M.T. (1962) "On the Social Psychology of the Psychological Experiment: With Particular Reference to Demand Characteristics and their Implications," American Psychologist 17: 776—83.[CrossRef]
- Piaget, J. (1951) The Child's Conception of the World. Savage, MD: Littlefield Adams.
- Pickett, S.T.A., Kolasa, J. and Jones, C.G. (1994) Ecological Understanding: The Nature of Theory and the Theory of Nature. New York: Academic Press.
- Pimm, S.L. (1991) Balance of Nature? Ecological Issues in the Conservation of Species and Communities. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
- Scott, M. (1995) The Young Oxford Book of Ecology. New York: Oxford University Press.
- Smith, C.P. (2000) "Content Analysis and Narrative Analysis," in H.T. Reis and C.M. Judd (eds) Handbook of Research Methods in Social and Personality Psychology, pp. 313—35. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
- Smith, E.L. and Anderson, C.W. (1986) "Alternative Student Conceptions of Matter Cycling in Ecosystems," Paper presented to the Annual Meeting of the National Association for Research in Science Teaching, San Francisco.
- Stringham, T.K., Krueger, W.C. and Thomas, D.R. (2001) "Application of Non-equilibrium Ecology to Rangeland Riparian Zones," Journal of Range Management 54: 210—17.[Web of Science]
- Tamir, P. and Zohar, A. (1991) "Anthropomorphism and Teleology in Reasoning about Biological Phenomena," Science Education 22: 57—67.
- Tytler, R., Duggan, S. and Gott, R. (2001) "Public Participation in an Environmental Dispute: Implications for Science Education," Public Understanding of Science 10: 343—64.[Medline]
[Order article via Infotrieve]
- Wood-Robinson, C. (1995) "Children's Biological Ideas: Knowledge about Ecology, Inheritance, and Evolution," in S.M. Glynn and R. Duit (eds) Learning Science in the Schools: Research Reforming Practice, pp. 111—30. Mahwah, NJ: Erlbaum.
- Wu, J. and Loucks, O.L. (1995) "From Balance of Nature to Hierarchical Patch Dynamics: A Paradigm Shift in Ecology," Quarterly Review of Biology 70: 439—66.[CrossRef]
Public Understanding of Science, Vol. 16, No. 4,
393-406 (2007)
DOI: 10.1177/0963662505063022
 CiteULike  Complore  Connotea  Del.icio.us  Digg  Reddit  Technorati  Twitter What's this?
|
|
